A committee infinite number of absentee and abductees set up by the National Council for Human Rights, headed by “Nasser Amin” to prepare a list of the number \101 people – including a number of university students – their parents reported their disappearance \after they were detained by the Egyptian security services without reaching their places of detention until this moment, and the list mentioned by reference to our database by the “freedom seekers” monitor to show the coverage of the list for the time period between July 8, 2013 until August 19, 2015, a time dimension between the oldest and the most recent history of the disappearance cases on the list.
Given the number of students who have been subjected to enforced disappearance mentioned in the list ther time and distance covered, proved the existence of gaps concerning the accuracy of the information that was displayed, in addition to the obvious contradiction between the reality of what we’ve “freedom seekers” monitor monitored and documented, and what is reportedly listed by the National Council for Human Rights During the same time period, the following offers you a statement by the ” freedom seekers” monitor to show you the gaps of information and commenting on the list:
First, the data monitored by the Committee in accordance with what has been mentioned in the list analysis:
First: List Committee infinite number of absentee and disappeared offered a number of students who have been subjected to enforced disappearance after they were detained, but they are not currently under enforced disappearance, which turned up they were included in criminal cases and were detained pending investigation, where they are currently being held in police lockups are known for their families and their lawyers , Below we offer you a number of these students and the names of their data:
1. Islam Ali El-Maati, a student at the Faculty of Science Damietta University, and Chairman of the Federation of University Students:
He was arrested from his home on Saturday, July 25, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Wednesday, August 5, 2015 at the headquarters of “talkha” police station.
2. Mohammed Antar Ahmed Abdul Hamid, a student at the Faculty of Engineering, Zagazig University:
He was arrested from a street on Monday, July 27, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Wednesday, August 19, 2015 he is held in the Central Security camp in Tenth of Ramadan.
3. Ahmed Rifai Feki, a student at the Faculty of Computer and Information Sciences, Ain Shams University:
He was arrested from an apartment on Saturday, July 11, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Saturday, October 3, 2015 then appeared in”Helwan” court.
4. Atef Abdul Rahman Hussein, a student at the Faculty of Languages and Translation, Al-Azhar University:
He was arrested in one of the streets on Tuesday, July 14, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Tuesday, September 22, 2015 then appeared in “Manshiya” court in Alexandria.
5. Amar Adel Zine El Abidine, a student at the Faculty of Commerce – Ain Shams University English Division:
He was arrested from a street in Nasr City in Cairo on Monday, June 22, 2015 and then was taken to an unknown destination where he was enforced disappeared until noon on Sunday, June 28, 2015 at the headquarters on behalf of Fifth Avenue.
6. Mohammed Abdul Malik Abdul Malik, a student at the Faculty of Tourism Helwan University:
He was arrested from his home on Thursday, July 9, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Thursday, August 13, 2015 then appeared at the headquarters on behalf of Fifth Avenue.
7. Abdulhadi Hammam Alawadla, a student at the Faculty of Engineering Mansoura University:He was arrested in a street on Friday, July 31, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Monday, August 3, 2015 at the headquarters of first on behalf of Mansoura.
8. Ahmed Hassan Saad, a student at the Faculty of Science University of Beni Suef:
He was arrested in one of the streets on Saturday, July 11, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he was underenforced disappearance until noon on Saturday, August 1, 2015 at the headquarters on behalf of the BPA.
9. Kareem Abdul Moez Al-Saeed, a student engineering Shubra:
He was arrested from his home on Thursday, August 6, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon in he appeared in mid-September of 2015 in Tora prison.
Second: List of number of absentee and disappeared offered and the number of students who have been subjected to enforced disappearance after they were detained, but they are not currently under enforced disappearance or even arrest, where they were released either on the pending issues of financial bail, or without the inclusion of any issues or display, and among these students:
1. Saad Abdasameea Dweik, a student at the Institute of Higher Engineering Al-Ahram:
Was arrested on Sunday, June 28, 2015 from a branch of the Association “message” area of Dokki, and then he was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Wednesday, August 19, 2015 at the headquarters on behalf of the “Osim,” to continue his imprisonment until he was released on Saturday, November 7, 2015 at the disposal of the case and financial bail of 5,000 pounds.
2. Saeed Al-Badawi, a student at Al Azhar University:
He was arrested from a street in the evening on Monday, June 8, 2015, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon on Monday, July 27, 2015 was released on the same day.
3. Omar Abdel Wahab Hussein, student at the Faculty of Arts, University of Minya:
He was arrested on campus in Minya on Tuesday, December 16, 2014, and then was taken to an unknown destination where he remained under enforced disappearance until noon of the month of November of 2015 to be released directly without having a record against him.
Third: List Committee infinite number of absentee and offered a number of the disappeared (3) Only students who have been subjected to enforced disappearance after they were detained under enforced disappearances until the present moment, the three students’ names and their data came as follows:
1. Ibrahim Amer Shehata, a student at the Faculty of Arts, Ain Shams University:
He was arrested in one of the subway stations on Wednesday, July 22, 2015, and lasts until this moment under forced hide.
2. Abdul Hamid Abdul Salam Mohammed, a student at the Faculty of Sharia and Law of Al-Azhar University – Tnt Branch:
He was arrested on Wednesday, August 14, 2015 in the resolution of the protest of anti-system that existed in “Rabi’a” sq at Nasr City, Cairo, he is forced hidden up to this moment.
3. Amr Abdel Moneim Ibrahim Metwally, good student Academy in Maadi:
He was arrested on Monday, July 8, 2013, in known as “the events of the Republican Guard” events, and still disappeared until the moment.
Second, to comment on the cases that have not been mentioned in the list:
First: List Committee infinite number of absentee and disappeared did not address to mention any of the students who were killed outside the framework of the law by the Egyptian security forces after they arrested and forced disappearance , tortured to death during the period of disappearance, where we were at the “freedom seekers” monitor monitored during the time period covered by the list that to monitor and document the number (6) students were killed under torture during the period of their disappearance, we offer you the names and data asking them as follows:
1. Mohammed Yahya Ramadan, a student at the Faculty of Law, Ain Shams University:
Was arrested on the third day on Monday, November 3, 2015, where he was taken to an undisclosed location until his body appeared on Sunday, November 16, 2015 at the headquarters of “Gardens dome” section has been proven that he died as a result of being tortured in the duration of his disappearance.
2. Islam Attiyto Salah al-Din, a student at the Faculty of Engineering, Ain Shams University:
He was arrested on Tuesday, May 19, 2015, and then his body was found dumped in the desert of the fifth assemble in Cairo, and bearing signs of torture, in addition to a stable five bullets to his body.
Second: List of number of absentee and disappeared number (25) a college student just been subjected to enforced disappearance, although we “freedom seekers” monitored during the same time monitored the number of (546) students from Egyptian universities and institutes were all were forced to hide Following the detention, which means that the number listed only about 4% of cases of enforced disappearance against the university students without mentioning any other cases.
Third: List of number of absentee and disappeared did not mention any of the students who have been victims of the crime of enforced disappearance during the above time mentioned, and even though we “freedom seekers” monitor monitored the number (21) of college student have been subjected to enforced disappearance during the same time period .
Fourth, the list restrict the number of absentees and disappeared didn’t mention the number of university students who have already turned up after a period of enforced disappearances, the list did not address the scores of students who are still being enforced disappearances since long periods of up to years were not disclosed place of detention until the moment, the following offer you the details of one of these students, for example, but not limited to:
“Omar Mohammed Ali Hammad,” the student Faculty of Engineering, Al-Azhar University:
Viewed student last time on Wednesday, August 14, 2015 inside an armored Egyptian army during the sit anti-system events and which existed in “Rabi’a” field of Nasr City, Cairo at the time, it was not reached fate or whereabouts of the student detention until the present moment .
It is worth mentioning that with the student who provided notification to the Attorney General of his disappearance number 12060 dated 06/11/2014 and has referred the communication to the east of Cairo in 1394 on behalf of a number also enclose 800 number.
Came this remarkable disparity between the number of actual cases of enforced disappearances that have been monitored and documented many of them, and the numbers that the Commission limit the number of absentees and Disappeared of the National Council for Human Rights viewing, came to ask many inquires about accredited by the National Council for Human Rights Monitoring Mechanism, and exciting to doubts and concerns about the possibility of politicization of the Human Rights Council in favor of the Egyptian state at the expense of hundreds of students in Egyptian universities and institutes who have been subjected to enforced disappearance, especially after the remarks, “Nasser Amin,” President of the Human Rights Council on “Cooperative curve hard,” which Atkhaddth Egyptian Interior Ministry on cases of enforced disappearance , without reference reveal the nature of this cooperation, where the President of the Council said that the Interior Ministry responded with a number (24) Note the disappearance of origin (51) Note has been identified places and the reasons for their detention, without legal these reasons survey or investigation into the incident exposed after arrest – illegal – enforced disappearance.
Comments